Swipe through the issue, one card at a time.
1 of 14
What happened?
The Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) held protests in Delhi. It wants Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar to resign. On 10 October, police detained founder Abhijeet Dipke and two other leaders at Delhi airport. A court ordered their release on 11 October. On 16 October, police detained Dipke again before a planned march.
2 of 14
Why does it matter?
The protests link to voter-list revisions. Voter lists decide who can vote. The events also raise a question: where can people protest in Delhi? Police removed Jantar Mantar's status as an official protest site on 12 October. Traders near Connaught Place and Khan Market also report losses.
3 of 14
What do the law and the Constitution say?
The sources name no exact section of law for the detentions, the notice or the trespass charge. Article 19(1)(b) of the Constitution protects the right to assemble peacefully without arms. Article 19(3) allows reasonable limits for public order. No source we read applied these Articles to this case. No court ruling on the protest curbs was found.
4 of 14
What does each side say?
The CJP and Dipke say Delhi is being shut down, and ask what law he broke. Police say they closed the park for administrative reasons and that prohibitory orders applied. A traders' body says protesters should use approved sites. Critics of the voter-list revision say it helps the BJP more than other parties.
5 of 14
What is still undecided?
No court ruling was found on the Jantar Mantar change. None was found on the 16 October notice or detention. The notes do not say whether a case from the 11 October release is still open. The Election Commission's reply to the resignation demand was not found. What happened at the 16 October march is also unclear.
6 of 14
Facts and figures
CJP volunteers who entered Jantar Mantar on 13 October: About 20
New protest venues named by police on 12 October: 3
CJP leaders jailed for alleged trespass: 2 leaders, 5 days
Protesters detained on each of 10 and 11 October: Hundreds
Start time of the 16 October march: 5pm
Traders' claimed daily loss: Rs 5-7 crore
Time the BJP has been in power, per Reuters: More than 12 years
7 of 14
Supporters argue
CJP supporters say protests make officials answer on voter lists and exams. They say the curbs on marches are too tight.
8 of 14
Critics argue
Critics of the CJP marches say protesters should follow police rules and use approved sites. Police say prohibitory orders applied.
9 of 14
Constitutional lens
Protesters say the curbs limit their rights to speech and assembly. A rights voice told Al Jazeera that peaceful protest is protected under international human rights law.
10 of 14
Economic lens
Khan Market traders say the protests cost them Rs 5-7 crore a day. The method behind that figure was not found.
11 of 14
Argued benefit for India
Supporters say open protest keeps officials answerable. They say it lets young people raise concerns on voter lists and exams.
12 of 14
Argued risk for India
Others say road closures and lost trade harm the public. They say unauthorised marches can break the rules in force.
13 of 14
Jantar Mantar protest-site order
On 12 October, Delhi Police removed Jantar Mantar's status as an official protest site. It named three new venues. The notes give no law number for this order. We found no court ruling on it.
14 of 14
What the sources show
Established: Police detained Abhijeet Dipke on 10 and 16 October. Reuters says a court ordered his release on 11 October. Police removed Jantar Mantar's protest-site status on 12 October. Authorities closed Central Park before the 16 October march. Claimed by one side: The CJP and Dipke say Delhi is being shut down and ask what law he broke. Claimed by the other side: Police say the park was closed for administrative reasons and prohibitory orders applied. Traders say the protests cost them Rs 5-7 crore a day. Not yet decided: No court ruling was found on the Jantar Mantar change or the 16 October detention. The court behind the 11 October order is not named in our notes. What happened at the march is unclear.